through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: getting (re)started with @Paravellex's awesome fic through shadowed eyes tonight!!
GG: ive actually read a couple chapters before, but it was a long while back and i want to start at the beginning

GG: okay i remember the early structure of the story being cinematic as heck so this chapter title is exciting lol
GG: one of the things i genuinely liked quite a bit about the epilogues was their pacing and structure/act-division, it felt very intentional
GG: that makes sense as something which can come about from a work released all at once, ofc—and while this fic is serial, its also a direct parallel with the eps! i dont think ill be revisiting the epilogues in synchrony or anything but i suspect that echoes of the structural form of that work might be heard here if you listen for them

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: oh heck i just realized the fic mustve surpassed 100k words really recently!! kudos on that!! @Paravellex

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: [extremely fictive system voice] me

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: i distinctly recall finding this a particularly concise, easy to understand explanation of the difference between relevance and essentiality! i also think its very poignantly positioned at the start of a long story and i take it itll be a good theme or framework to keep in mind throughout, alongside everything else the fic has as a(n) (in)dependent work in its own right :dragneyes:

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: snrk i love roxy
GG: this is also such a good line to introduce her with

through shadowed eyes, ch1 (food mention) 

GG: roxy loves callie...
GG: she loves rose, too!! i mean theres a reason shes listened this long heheh
GG: also god i do appreciate the nod to cherub-meat-nomching here. same with "beautiful green-skulled companion"—like, callie is weird and not of this world (not that any of them exactly are) and has her own unusual ways of being, but thats never a bad thing really, shes appreciated by those close to her for exactly who she is
GG: i know thats a little cliche but its still really heartwarming yknow!!
GG: the sentences about going to the park or a cafe or just hanging out together are also a big part of that, like, really illustrating that their life is not nearly as strange or alien as a surface look at the cherub might have you guess
GG: theyre just normal!! theyre just chill!! or, at least, so our perception of their lives establishes them

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: [an awkward moment of silence pervades the metaphorical gathering, a hollow whistle in the wind addressing the juju-drugged elephant in the room just as thoroughly as any words could]

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: god that sentence owns. its nothing fancy but using the bell shadow as a very tangible telling of time is so effective.

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: pfffheh
GG: this is genuinely interesting meta (and you can TELL shes only just getting started. 1.5 hours in. lol) and i would absolutely riff off it with rose waaay too late into the night-turned-morning
GG: but also yes roxy thank you lol
GG: i remember there is a bunch of good stuff very soon to come and it is most certainly not (just) canonicity meta

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: i also want to give a really strong shout-out to the character voices here!! all the lines in this fic are GOOD

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: this is such a thesis statement lmao
GG: i wonder how long she spent refining this one, or if it just comes to her naturally

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: snrk exactly lol
GG: i think ive seen this explained before somewhere although i still basically dont know what the deal with the frog switch is
GG: and its true, it just really doesnt matter to the story

GG: honestly id argue the degree to which lord english Has To Happen doesnt, that much, either? although i suppose thats more due to my natural lack of inclination towards "truth" mattering all that much: these are just stories, they dont need to fit into a neat, 100%-internally-consistent canon, and a sense of accepting looseness to your reality can be remarkably freeing
GG: i know thats not a philosophy everyone shares too, though!

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: this is intense, tbh!!
GG: pretty awesome storytelling stroke to make mystery surrounding the raw canonical value of a story be actually kinda riveting, and i dunno if it could happen outside of homestuck, but it is cool as heck here

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: oh god i love her. there is so so much roxy has no idea shes yet to face, not long from now.

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: mwahahahahaha

GG: this right here feels like an epilogues move. probably a homestuck-proper move, too, but i think the prose nails it in particularly powerfully.
GG: meta bullshit careening gay into romance drama? oh you know it

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: hoogh i got nothing special to add onto all that relationship introspection, but it is *strong* stuff. so many complicated feelings, so little resolution. it fits a prologue so well.

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

GG: the chunk of the house broken off from the rest... geez
GG: i kinda wonder if all of us felt that way, sometimes, or if it was just a harlegbert thing, but i think it must be at least a little essential to the kind of isolation sburb-and-surrounding puts you through

Follow

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

@quasar i gotta go to bed but this liveread-analysis has me grinning from ear to ear thank you so much

· · Web · 1 · 0 · 1

through shadowed eyes, ch1 

@Paravellex
GG: <3 glad to hear!!!
GG: i gotta sleep real soon too lol i ended up having less time than expected
GG: but reading this has been a blast thank you for sharing it again and writing this whole marvelous wondeful thing!!

Sign in to participate in the conversation
SHRIKE CLUB

ONLY CREATE ACCOUNT IF YOU PERSONALLY KNOW AN ADMINISTRATOR, AND IDENTIFY YOURSELF IN YOUR APPLICATION. YOU DO NOT NEED A SHRIKE CLUB ACCOUNT TO FOLLOW SHRIKE CLUB USERS. A PERSONAL FEDERATED SOCIAL MEDIA INSTANCE FOR SMALL CARNIVOROUS BIRDS BY SMALL CARNIVOROUS BIRDS