good morning, magpie 

"we're all just hallucinations anyway" this bodes well for the fictive prospects....

good morning, magpie 

"life is too short to be anything other than exactly what you are" Sarah may have some major themes

good morning, magpie; godfeels: visions of everything 

"the blank page" prologuey page is definitely in conversation with the first section of MAGPIE's metatomic fic

good morning, magpie 

fvrther thematic throvghlines as the magpie accepts death with both rage and relief (and then doesn^t die)

good morning, magpie 

Determining whether "lady" is an address of honor or an epithet is a thrilling little game.

- RL

good morning, magpie; godfeels 

realized while reading the description of the first moment of the apocalypse that the narrator of that one part of godfeels may have described this one. don^t think so on review thovgh

good morning, magpie 

this magpie is so long winded lmao I wanna give him a wedgie

good morning, magpie 

really digging the not-explaining-the-setting approach. I'm really intrigued by Asthur and the Great Worm-Sloth and I would just be rolling my eyes if I were directly told what they are

good morning, magpie; the godfeels experience 

i^m throwing a theory out now, on behalf of myself, the robot milf, and Soph, that the connection between this book and THE QVILT is a dark tower type thing. magpie is somehow derived from another version of the story told in good morning, magpie.

good morning, magpie 

Sarah Zedig used homestuck to trick me into reading Redwall: Zombies

good morning, magpie 

this is reductive and inaccurate but I think funny. I am enjoying the book.

good morning, magpie 

the pacing is very strange to my current reader-brain. I'm used to stories where in the midst of the larger story, an episode conflict is introduced and then lingered on or disregarded for several chapters or even most of a single book. in good morning, magpie episodic conflicts are resolved shortly after they are introduced, such as the encounter with Adam and his followers, which lasts only a few pages.

this sounds like a criticism but it's not -- I ran out of characters

good morning, magpie 

the quicker episodic pace works, not only because there's nothing wrong with that (I chose episodic for a reason) but because good morning, magpie is in a lot of ways closer to a fable than the kind of story that I'm used to. I feel like using animals as the cast to draw the mind to Aesop probably wasn't an accident.

I could just ask if the fable quality is intentional lol

good morning, magpie 

we^re not very far in. not enovgh reading time and soph insists on spending half of what we have on they phone. speaking of which.

good morning, magpie; godfeels 

So with the post-Adam scene of the Darkness, I realize that it does somewhat resemble Epigone. Not in a way that necessarily makes me think they're the same THING; in fact i think they probably actively aren't, as the story seems to be about "sometimes awful, AWFUL things happen for no reason, no earns this even if they're irredeemable, because some things are ARBITRARY" and Epigone very fundamentally Desires things.

good morning, magpie; godfeels 

The tendrils of the darkness stabbing forward and corrupting people resembles a combination of the Halo vision of the horrible all consuming cult crossed with Roserot -- though it also very much reminds me of the Hunger, from TAZ

Which is 100% not me saying "oh derivative" just for the record; with Epigone it's me identifying themes in Sarah's work, and with TAZ it's me saying "man tendrils of corrupting darkness are fuckin scary"

good morning, magpie; godfeels 

But yeah the arbitrary nature of the apocalypse (from what I can see) reminds me of the narrator of godfeels breaking objectivity Kayfabe and talking about "we have seen worlds consumed by black holes that came out of fucking nowhere"

good morning, magpie 

Genuinely a huge fan of the kinda, interlude about Adam's backstory. From a narrative standpoint I'm a huge fan. It's a good story also but damn if it didn't break my heart. Jenna, but especially the Bears. Poor lil Rowan. I have a huge weakness for like..... children being tormented for no reason :(

good morning, magpie 

But yeah, Adam died, and *then* we got his backstory, and I think that's pretty cool as a narrative movement.

good morning, magpie 

Can magpies and grackles mate :( is that why Emma's eggs were sad :( I mean, obviously it's because they were barren, but is that why :(

Follow

good morning, magpie 

Finding out that Crow had once been a community leader also was a punch to the gut!

· · Web · 1 · 0 · 1

good morning, magpie 

I suspected Crow had some connection to The Watchers but "The Watchers destroy all that they touch!" took me by surprise anyway

good morning, magpie 

in Part 2 the episodic nature of the conflicts becomes a bit less short-term; individual scenes are still very directly advancing the plots more than I'm used to in the shit i've been reading most, but the splitting of narrative time into present and past has really shifted the pace. It's pretty interesting.

good morning, magpie 

Me: I think this book is probably largely about how much suffering is arbitrary and cause less.
[1 page later]
crow: we've done nothing to you
falcon: that's the beauty of it. destruction without provocation. absolute chaos.

good morning, magpie 

Swan: ... wood carvings aren't legs!
Coyote(?): maybe they never tried hard enough?
Crow: are you implying that wood carvings are lazy?
Coyote(?): That would be ridiculous.

good morning, magpie 

Wesley is a top grade character and I knew he wouldn't live. rip Wesley

good morning, magpie 

Ngl the twist with Crow's backstory took me by surprise in a very good way. We laughed out loud when we read "Emma and Marley looked back at him"

of course it wasn't that their eggs were barren, it's that she was having an affair because Crow sucks.

Then he abandons them rather than seeking help and WOW. and swan was right about that -- he shouldn't have done that, but also, it wouldn't have made any difference.

good morning, magpie 

crow: gets high function prosthetic limbs
me: is crow a vriska, the greatest threa--

good morning, magpie 

Crow's conscious decision to discard his self loathing with the little plummet-then-fly stunt is so melodramatic, he's so melodramatic

good morning, magpie 

cinematic parallels between crow knocking swan unconscious and Kanaya knocking karkat unconscious

good morning, magpie 

I'm really liking the technique of doing a sort of intermission telling the backstory of a character who was introduced and died in the previous chapter. It really does a good job of occupying a reader with the character's actual arc rather than using flashbacks during the arc to occupy us with speculation on where the story is going with them, if that makes any sense?

good morning, magpie 

if chapter 1 had included the Adam flashbacks I would have known the story was giving him weight in a way that would have kind of damaged the value of his presence?

good morning, magpie 

Everest: I'd love to carve you.
Wesley: .... That would hurt.

good morning, magpie 

right, we left off right after "Asthvr Alanna" threw vs for a loop. haven^t fovnd ovt if that^s like sister for nvns or if swan has been god all along

good morning, magpie 

oh shit we fell for it, that wasn^t swan at all

good morning, magpie 

or is there weird time shit

good morning, magpie 

weird time shit it is. what the fvck are the watchers

good morning, magpie 

at least crow didn^t qvantvm leap to invent religion, I don^t think soph or the rogve covld handle this also being warriors

Show newer
Sign in to participate in the conversation
SHRIKE CLUB

ONLY CREATE ACCOUNT IF YOU PERSONALLY KNOW AN ADMINISTRATOR, AND IDENTIFY YOURSELF IN YOUR APPLICATION. YOU DO NOT NEED A SHRIKE CLUB ACCOUNT TO FOLLOW SHRIKE CLUB USERS. A PERSONAL FEDERATED SOCIAL MEDIA INSTANCE FOR SMALL CARNIVOROUS BIRDS BY SMALL CARNIVOROUS BIRDS