I will be attempting to score and write a short blurb for Every Doctor Who Story I watch or listen to. You can access it here:
Writer (count of stories I've heard by that writer): Average score
[Minimum 5 stories]
–––
Robert Shearman (5 stories): 5.0
John Dorney (12 stories): 3.6
Marc Platt (6 stories): 3.1
Eddie Robson (5 stories): 3.0
Nicholas Briggs (9 stories): 2.8
Matt Fitton (17 stories): 2.8
Dorney and Fitton are the primary eighth Doctor writers, and both are capable of great stories. But Dorney’s ceiling and floor are both much higher